Local SEO
Fake Google Reviews: How to Spot, Report and Avoid Them
Fake Google reviews: how to spot them, report them step by step, handle review extortion and why buying them breaks Google policy and the FTC rule.

Fake Google reviews are reviews that do not reflect a real experience: paid for, written by the business itself, by employees or by a competitor. Google bans them, US federal rules ban selling and buying them, and you can report them. Here is how to spot and report them.
In the United States, "fake google reviews" gets about 880 searches a month, with a keyword difficulty of 10 (Pengu Insights, 18 Nov 2026). Two kinds of people type it: owners hit by fake reviews and owners tempted to buy some. This guide is for both.
What counts as a fake review for Google?
For Google, any review that does not reflect a genuine experience is fake. Its fake engagement policy spells out the cases:
- Paid reviews, whether paid in cash or in kind.
- Content posted from multiple accounts by one person or at their request.
- Incentives: payments, discounts, free goods or services for posting, changing or removing a review.
- Competitor reviews posted on your profile to damage your reputation.
- Conflicts of interest: current or former employees, or anyone with a contractual or consulting relationship with the business.
The same policy bans businesses from discouraging negative reviews or selectively asking for positive ones. Asking the right way is a different thing, and I cover it in how to get more Google reviews.
How to spot fake Google reviews
No single signal proves a review is fake. Several together justify reporting it. These are the signals I check when a business asks me for help:
| Signal | What to look for |
|---|---|
| Sudden wave | Many 1-star or 5-star reviews within a few days, with no reason like a grand opening |
| Empty text | Generic phrases that could fit any business, without a single detail of the service |
| Reviewer profile | Accounts with no photo, few reviews, or reviews in distant cities on the same day |
| No record | You cannot find that person in your calendar, invoices or orders |
| Repeated pattern | The same writing style or the same typos across different reviewers |
Before you report, take dated screenshots and save the link to each review. If you need to escalate later, evidence beats memory.
And do not reply to a suspicious review by calling the author a liar. Google decides whether it is fake. If it turns out to be a real customer you forgot, your reply stays there forever. A neutral line such as "We can't find your visit in our records, please reach out so we can look into it" protects you either way.
How to report a fake review step by step
If the review is on your profile, you report it from your Business Profile. Google's help page on how to report inappropriate reviews gives four steps:
- Open your Business Profile and select Read reviews (1 min).
- Next to the review, select Report (1 min).
- Pick a reason (2 min). Google gives spam and profanity as examples. Choose the one that best describes the problem.
- Send the report and note the date (1 min). Google says evaluation typically takes several days.
If Google decides the review does not break its policies, you can submit a one-time appeal through its Reviews Management Tool. And remember that Google asks you not to report a review just because you dislike it.
If the fake review sits on another business, say a competitor packed with suspicious 5-star reviews, anyone can report it in Google Maps. The Maps help page on reporting content describes the path: open the business, go to the Reviews tab, open the review's three-dot menu, select Report review, fill in the form and submit it (5 min).
Review extortion: a wave of 1-stars and a demand for money
There is a specific scam: you suddenly get a pile of 1-star and 2-star reviews, then someone asks for money, goods or services to remove them. Google has a page on negative review extortion scams, and its advice is clear:
- Do not pay or negotiate. Google warns that paying can encourage more attempts and does not guarantee removal.
- Gather evidence right away. Dated screenshots of the demands with contact details, links to the reviews, usernames, phone numbers or emails used, and when it all started.
- Use the merchant extortion report form. Include your details, your profile link, the affected reviews and how they contacted you.
That channel is only for extortion. Reviews that break the rules for other reasons go through the normal report process.
Why buying reviews costs more than it saves
Buying reviews exposes you to two penalties: Google's and the law's. Google's is on its page about Business Profile restrictions: beyond removing the violating reviews, it can block new reviews for a set period, unpublish your existing ones and show customers a warning that fake reviews were removed. Google emails owners before it applies a restriction.
The law depends on where you operate. In the United States, the FTC's rule on consumer reviews and testimonials took effect on October 21, 2024. It makes it unlawful to write, create or sell reviews that misrepresent that the reviewer exists or used the product, or that misrepresent their experience.
The same rule bans offering incentives conditioned on a review expressing a particular sentiment, and it covers review suppression too, such as groundless legal threats or intimidation to get a review taken down. If your business is in Spain, the Unfair Competition Act also covers fake reviews, which I explain in the Spanish version of this guide.
What works instead of buying
What works is slower and carries no risk: ask every customer, with the official link, at the right moment. It is all in how to get more Google reviews.
If a real review hurts, do not bury it under fake ones. Answer it well, as I explain in how to respond to negative reviews.
And if you are still setting up your profile, do it without shortcuts from day one. Start with how to get on Google Maps. A profile that starts clean has nothing to hide when Google checks its reviews.
Want me to look at your profile?
If you suspect fake reviews or a campaign against you, send me your profile and I will record a free 90-second diagnostic video with what I see and where I would start. That works wherever your business is.
If you run an English-speaking business in Madrid and want your profile and reviews handled every month, my local SEO service in Madrid costs €450 a month plus VAT, with a three-month minimum and then month to month. I do not sell reviews or buy them. I am not a lawyer: if your case has legal weight, I will tell you to talk to one.
Frequently asked questions
How do I report fake Google reviews?
If the review is on your profile, open your Business Profile, select Read reviews, choose Report next to the review, pick a reason and send it. If it is on another business, open that business in Google Maps, go to the review and use the three-dot menu to select Report review.
How long does Google take to remove a fake review?
Google says review evaluation typically takes several days. If it decides the review does not break its policies, you can submit a one-time appeal through its Reviews Management Tool.
Is it illegal to buy Google reviews?
In the United States, the FTC rule that took effect on October 21, 2024, bans buying reviews conditioned on a particular sentiment and creating or selling fake ones. Google bans paid reviews regardless and can restrict your profile. Other countries, including Spain, have their own laws.
What can I do if a competitor posts fake reviews about me?
Report them to Google with the right reason, save dated screenshots and links, and do not reply with accusations. If the claims are false and hurt your business, talk to a lawyer about your options.
Will Google remove a review just because it is negative?
No. Google asks businesses not to report a review just because they disagree with it, and it only removes reviews that break its policies. A real bad experience stays up.
Sources
- 01Google Maps: Fake engagement policy
- 02Google: Report inappropriate reviews on your Business Profile
- 03Google Maps: Report or fix content
- 04Google: Report negative review extortion scams on your Business Profile
- 05Google: Business Profile restrictions for policy violations
- 06FTC: Trade Regulation Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials (Federal Register, 2024)

Christian Monge
Teaches AI workshops at EAE Business School, builds AI second brains with Obsidian and Claude Code, co-founded the competitive-intelligence SaaS Pengu Insights and publishes his Claude skills for free. Trains teams in English and Spanish from Madrid.
More about meLocal SEO
Get found on Google Maps and in AI answers.
Profile, reviews, service pages and AI visibility for small businesses in Spain. €450 a month, three-month minimum, then month to month.
See local SEOKeep reading

Local SEO
How to Get More Google Reviews Without Breaking Rules
How to get more Google reviews the legitimate way: the official link and QR code, when to ask, copy-ready templates and what Google and the FTC ban outright.

Local SEO
How to Get on Google Maps: Listing and Verification
How to get on Google Maps step by step: create or claim your listing, pass verification without getting stuck, and learn what decides who shows up in the map.

Local SEO
How to Optimize Google Business Profile Listings
How to optimize Google Business Profile listings: categories, description, services, photos, posts and links, per Google's specs, plus a monthly routine.